What the iPad Can't Do | The New York Review of Books

| | Comments (0) | TrackBacks (0)
photo of American Political Tradition.jpg


Sue Halpern makes a point I'm obsessed with because I mark up my books so much:

"One of the guilty pleasures of an actual, ink-on-paper book is the possibility of marking it up--underlining salient passages, making notes in the margins, dog-earing a page. While it's true that some electronic book platforms for the iPad allow highlighting (it even looks like you've used a fat neon yellow or blue or orange marker), and a few--most notably Kindle and Barnes and Noble but not iBooks--allow you to type notes, they barely take advantage of being digital. It is not possible to "capture" your notes and highlights, to organize, compile, arrange, or to print them out. Until there is a seamless way to do this, marginalia will remain sequestered in the margins, and the promise of electronic books will be unrealized"

It's strange, given that the power of the iPhone and iPad is that they allow their users to make applications and find cool new ways to manipulate content. That's what I think is behind the new iPhone 4's promise of video. I know nothing about how Apple makes, markets or designs their products but I can't imagine that they really think there is a huge use case for people using the cameras to hold video chats. There are business uses, of course, but won't most people want to chat the old way, where you don't have to worry about your hair and makeup?

It seems like the kind of non-evolution you'd expect from Radio Shack which is always giving you special additions to gadgets that you don't want--an alarm clock with built-in nail file. But with Apple won't people find some nutty way to use the camera technology that will be extremely viral and sweep the nation? Twitter meets chatroulette?

 

Is there a term for something that doesn't have a particular use case, but in this world where your users bend your products to fit their strange desires you make it anyway knowing that someone somewhere will warp it into the next best thing? Built-in Anticipatory Innovation?

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: What the iPad Can't Do | The New York Review of Books.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.johndickerson.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/350

Leave a comment